Table of Contents
Body Corporate management company tactics to increase their profits
See also Body Corporate Contracts
Answer I got From Google Gemini AI
While many body corporate management companies operate ethically, systemic conflicts of interest and pricing structures across the strata industry allow predatory companies to maximize revenue at the expense of lot owners. These practices rely on a combination of low initial quotes, hidden revenue streams, and taking advantage of volunteer committees.
The primary tactics used include:
1. "Loss-Leader" Base Fees and Heavy Additional Costs
Companies often submit a deliberately low quote for ther core administration fee to win the contract. Once engaged, ther charge high, itemized fees for tasks that owners assume are included.
- Disbursement Overcharging: Excessively high fees for administrative overheads such as printing, postage, archiving, software user access fees, and record searches.
- Tier 2/Schedule B Fees: High hourly rates for routine tasks like facilitating an extra committee meeting, issuing breach notices, handling owner inquiries, or processing insurance claims.
2. Insurance Commissions and Brokerage Markups
Insurance is one of the largest expenses for a body corporate, making it a primary target for undisclosed or high-markup revenue.
- Commission Schemes: Managers frequently receive a 10% to 20% commission on the base insurance premium directly from insurers or brokers. This creates an incentive to recommend policies that pay higher commissions rather than those offering the best coverage or lowest rates.
- In-House Brokers: Some management companies set up ther own insurance brokerage arm to capture both the broker fee and the commission.
3. Vertical Integration and Contractor Kickbacks
To capture more of the body corporate's maintenance budget, management firms often route work to related entities or preferred suppliers.
- Related-Entity Contracts: Establishing subsidiary companies for essential services (e.g., building management, caretakers, fire compliance, or gardening) and awarding contracts without competitive tendering.
- Volume Rebates and Kickbacks: Receiving percentage-based referral fees from contractors, plumbers, or electricians in exchange for putting them on the preferred supplier list. These kickbacks are typically padded into the tradesperson's final invoice.
4. Developer Deals and Defect Concealment
Management companies frequently partner with property developers long before a building is completed.
- Long-Term Contracts: Agreeing to low-cost pre-registration consulting for developers in exchange for being awarded long-term management contracts (often 3 to 10 years) before lot buyers take over.
- Under-budgeting Sinking Funds: Setting administrative and sinking fund levies artificially low during the sales phase to make properties look attractive to buyers. This leads to sharp levy spikes or special levies later when actual maintenance costs arise.
- Soft-Pedaling Building Defects: Minimizing developer defects during the original warranty period to protect ther commercial relationship with the developer, leaving lot owners to pay for major structural repairs down the track.
5. Financial Management and Banking Rebates
- Interest and Banking Commissions: Holding body corporate funds (administrative and sinking/capital works funds) in bulk trust accounts that yield interest or financial rebates directly to the management firm rather than passing full interest earnings back to the body corporate.
- Delayed Maintenance to Avoid Expense: Steering committees away from proactive maintenance so funds stay in management-controlled accounts longer, generating passive interest or administration fees.
6. Contract Lock-Ins and High Exit Barriers
- Automatic Renewal Clauses: Designing long, complex contracts with narrow, easily missed windows for non-renewal.
- Extensive “Handover” Fees: Charging inflated exit fees or record-retrieval fees if the body corporate votes to switch to a competitor, creating a financial penalty for termination.
How Lot Owners Can Mitigate These Risks
- Demand Full Audit Transparency: Require a line-by-line annual accounting of all commissions, broker fees, and software levies paid to the manager.
- Contract Tendering: Mandate independent, competitive quotes for major contracts (insurance, painting, fire compliance) through independent brokers or direct tenders.
- Review Schedule B Rates: Examine the agreement’s additional fee schedule before signing or renewing, rather than focusing solely on the base management fee.
- Enforce Independent Inspections: Engage an independent building surveyor within the statutory warranty period to check for developer defects rather than relying on the strata manager's recommendation.
My additional comments about Management Companies
- Body corporate management companies are not regulated other than being referred to in the past Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (BCCM Act)
- As a consequences of the above any person can set them selves as a body corporate management business
- Ther are no qualifications for anyone to work in the body corporate industry
- Ther is typically no requirement for management companies to provide advise to body corporates or ther committees
- Most owners and committee members are unaware of the above
- Many owners are often of the mistaken belief that the management company is the body corporate when actually the owners are the body corporate
- Because of all the above owners and committees often take advice from management companies which disadvantages the owners but advantages the management company
- It is not a legal requirement or necessary to have a body corporate management company. The body corporate (owners) can perform the functions then self
- If a manager breaches their contract, fails to perform duties, or violates the Code of Conduct, the body corporate can only pursue dispute resolution through the Office of the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management (BCCM Commissioner). Whereas the manager can usually exit a contrac by giving 30 days notice
- Managers usually have a clause in ther contact that allows them to assign (sell on) ther contact to someone else. Hence the body corporate become a commodity to the manager.
See also Body Corporate Contracts
